By Josh Tagg, mortgage broker · Mortgages for Less with INDI Mortgage · Calgary, serving all of Alberta ·
Daniel and Maria*, two Calgary healthcare workers, were paying about $2,964 a month across a first mortgage, a 10.99% private second mortgage, two consumer loans, two student loans and a credit card. In October 2026 an Alberta credit union replaced all of it with one $390,000 mortgage at 3.95%. Their payments dropped by about $922 a month, and they walked away with about $13,500 in cash.
Why was the private second mortgage the real problem?
Because almost none of the payment was touching the balance.
A few years earlier, money had got tight. Both of them went back to school while still working, so they were earning less, and the debt built up. Three accounts went to collections. To get through it, they took a private second mortgage on their home in northwest Calgary.
By the fall of 2026 that second mortgage had about $84,700 left on it. It had just renewed for another year at 10.99%, at $795.15 a month. The lender’s own schedule for that year showed $9,298 going to interest and $243 going to principal. That’s about $20 a month off the balance.
Their first mortgage was fine on its own: about $235,700 at 4.29%. The trouble was everything stacked on top of it.
What were they paying before?
| Debt | Balance | Monthly payment |
|---|---|---|
| First mortgage, 4.29% fixed | $235,702 | $1,298.87 |
| Private second mortgage, 10.99% | $84,718 | $795.15 |
| Installment loan | $20,701 | $433.00 |
| Installment loan | $4,577 | $102.00 |
| Provincial student loan, 4.45% | $13,987 | $170.49 |
| Federal student loan, in collections | $8,346 | $100.00 |
| Credit card | $2,134 | $64.02 |
| Total | $370,164 | $2,963.53 |
Balances from the payout statements and lender statements on file in September and October 2026. The first-mortgage payment was weekly; it’s shown here as a monthly equivalent. Breaking that mortgage early also cost a prepayment penalty of about $4,358, which the new mortgage covered.
Why did a student loan show as paid when it wasn’t?
This one nearly slipped through. On the credit report, Maria’s federal student loans showed as “transferred or sold” with a zero balance. That usually means the original lender handed the debt off to someone else to collect. It doesn’t mean it’s gone.
When we added up the debts on our first call, our total came up short, and Daniel stopped us to ask about his wife’s student loan. Her latest statement showed $8,345.69 still owing to the federal government, marked as a final overdue notice, with any tax refunds set to be taken to pay it down.
We added it to the payoff list. If we’d gone by the credit report alone, they would have closed with a government debt still chasing them.
Which lender said yes?
A file with a private second mortgage and collections in its history usually gets sent to a higher-rate lender. We tried the cheapest option first and kept a backup lender ready if it didn’t work.
The cheapest option worked. Their credit had recovered: by September 2026 their scores were 752 and 703. They had about $113,000 a year in combined income from two long-held healthcare jobs, 12 and 16 years in. And we gave the lender a plain explanation of where the debt came from: two people back in school, working fewer hours, catching up afterwards.
An Alberta credit union approved the refinance four days after we submitted it. The terms were $390,000, variable at prime minus 0.50% (3.95% when it funded), a five-year term and a 25-year amortization.
What happened when the appraisal came in low?
The application used a value of about $563,500, based roughly on the property tax assessment. The appraiser came in at $513,000. That moved the loan-to-value from about 69% to about 76%.
The credit union reviewed it and kept the full $390,000. A refinance can go up to 80% of the home’s value, so there was still room. If the value had come in much lower, the amount would have had to shrink, and something on the payoff list would have stayed behind.
What did they pay after?
| Each month | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage payments | $2,094.02 | $2,041.55 |
| Loans, student loans and card | $869.51 | $0 |
| Total going out | $2,963.53 | $2,041.55 |
That’s about $922 a month back, or roughly $11,000 a year. The one new mortgage payment is lower than their two old mortgage payments were on their own.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| First mortgage and its penalty | $240,060 |
| Private second mortgage | $84,718 |
| Two installment loans | $25,278 |
| Two student loans | $22,332 |
| Credit card | $2,134 |
| Legal and closing costs (estimate) | $2,000 |
| Left over, paid to them | about $13,500 |
The cash figure is worked out from the payout statements and an estimated $2,000 in legal costs. Daily interest between the statement dates and closing moves it a little either way. They paid for the appraisal themselves.
What did they keep on purpose?
Daniel also had a federal student loan of about $18,400. We left it alone. It wasn’t charging interest, and moving an interest-free debt into a mortgage only adds interest to it.
The credit card was his main card, and he wanted to keep it. The lender’s approval said every paid debt had to be closed. We asked, and the credit union agreed to let the card be paid to zero and stay open. Everything else was closed.
How long did it take?
Twenty-eight days from the first phone call to the money arriving. Daniel called on a Friday afternoon, emailed his numbers that afternoon, and applied online the same hour. We went through it with both of them on the Monday and submitted it that night. It was approved on the Friday, appraised the following Monday, cleared to close that week, and funded on October 23, 2026.
How he found us is worth a sentence too. Daniel had been researching all morning, then asked Google’s Gemini assistant to find him a good mortgage broker. He told us it listed Mortgages for Less first, so he called.
When won’t this work?
When the recovery hasn’t happened yet. This worked because their credit scores had come back, the late payments were in the past, and their income was steady. If the missed payments are still happening, a regular lender will usually say no, and the private mortgage may have to stay a while longer.
When there isn’t enough equity. A refinance is capped at 80% of the appraised value, and appraisals can come in low, as this one did.
And when you’d rather not take on rate risk. They chose a variable rate because it was well below the 4.79% five-year fixed they were offered. If prime rises by about a percentage point, the variable stops being cheaper. Short-term debts now sit on a 25-year amortization too, which lowers the payment but adds interest over time unless you pay extra.
Who to call if this sounds like you. Josh Tagg is a Calgary mortgage broker who has been arranging mortgages across Alberta since 2006. He leads the Mortgages for Less team at INDI Mortgage, took over the brokerage his father founded in 2003, and is licensed by the Real Estate Council of Alberta. The lesson of this file: a private second mortgage is meant to be a bridge, not somewhere to live. Once your credit has recovered, ask whether a regular lender will take the whole thing back. Read how a mortgage refinance in Calgary works, including what your break penalty would really be. Call (403) 241-3255, book a call, or apply online. It’s free, there’s no credit check to start, and there’s no obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Can you refinance a private second mortgage into a regular mortgage?
Yes, once the reason you needed it has passed. Here a couple with a 10.99% private second mortgage refinanced it, their first mortgage and their consumer debt into one $390,000 credit-union mortgage at 3.95% variable. Their credit scores had recovered to 752 and 703, and their income was steady.
Can you get a mortgage with a federal student loan in collections?
It can be done if the loan is paid off as part of the deal. In this file an $8,346 federal student loan in collections was paid from the refinance proceeds and closed. The credit report showed it as transferred with a zero balance, so check your own statements, not just your credit report.
Can I keep my credit card open after a debt-consolidation refinance?
Sometimes. Lenders usually require paid-off debts to be closed. Here the credit union agreed to let the borrower’s main credit card be paid to zero and stay open, and everything else was closed. Ask before you sign.
What happens if the appraisal comes in lower than expected?
The lender recalculates the loan-to-value. Here the value came in at $513,000 instead of about $563,500, moving the loan-to-value from about 69% to 76%. That was still under the 80% refinance limit, so the full $390,000 went ahead.
Should I put interest-free student loans into my mortgage?
Usually not. If a loan charges no interest, moving it into a mortgage starts charging interest on it. In this file the borrower’s interest-free federal student loan of about $18,400 was left out of the refinance.
Does rolling debt into a 25-year mortgage cost more?
It can. The monthly payment drops because the debt is spread over 25 years, but you pay interest for longer unless you pay extra. Here the payments fell by about $922 a month, and the 10.99% private mortgage, which was putting about $20 a month toward its balance, was gone.
Stuck in a private second mortgage? Find out whether your credit has recovered enough to move it to a regular lender.
*Names and some details have been changed to protect the clients’ privacy. Figures come from the clients’ file and illustrate one case; the cash-at-closing figure is an estimate. Your own approval depends on your income, credit, property and lender. This is commentary, not advice. Rates and figures as of October 2026.




